Thursday, March 01, 2007

More Allergy and Intolerance Testing Nonsense: Part 2

Pirate Mosaic
Allergy Magazine has recently published a feature on DIY Diagnosis. There is a reasonable introductory summary about the difficulties of gaining access to allergy diagnosis and management on the NHS. There is the usual sloppiness about referring to allergies and intolerance as if they are synonymous. The author uncritically reproduces a number of claims that are frequently repeated but I have yet to see substantiated:
[h]aving an allergy is now one of the most common health complaints in the UK, affecting an estimated 23 million people and four out of ten school children. Up to 40 per cent of the population are sensitive to the three most common allergens: dust mites, pollen and pets. Millions more are intolerant to certain foods, most commonly wheat and dairy.
There is the usual pop quiz where the reader is told that if they have 3 or more of a 16-item list of symptoms then they might have an allergy or food intolerance. The symptoms are the usual suspects: irritable bowel syndrome; constipation; bloating; migraines; anxiety; sinusitis; joint pains; fatigue; low immunity; itchy skin, rashes and eczema; acne or dry skin; itching, swollen lips and face; coughing or wheezing; shortness of breath; dry, itchy throat; diarrhoea or vomiting. Dr. Hadler writes about the medicalization of misery and would probably like a hands-up by anyone who hasn't experienced several of those symptoms over the last year.

The writer does make a handwave towards acknowledging that
[t]here is no clinically proven test for food intolerance yet, but the IgG blood test is the only test with scientific evidence to back up its reliability. [Emphasis added.]
She quotes advice from experts on what to look for in a test.
Liz Tucker, allergy nutrition expert and wellbeing consultant says, ‘Research any test well before you jump in. Some tests are very accurate and have scientific evidence to prove it. But others have no records of accuracy and no evidence to prove it works. Always go for a clinically validated test.’
Liz Tucker is one of the YorkTest-styled experts who endorses YorkTest's range. According to the writer of DIY Diagnosis,
Alex Gazzola, author of Living with Food Intolerance...agrees: ‘Don’t take advice from unqualified people offering unvalidated tests on the high street. I would avoid any test that has not been validated scientifically.’
Gazzola's book is available from YorkTest and endorsed by Allergy UK's Muriel Simmons. At some point, it would be very helpful if somebody other than this self-referential pool of experts were to claim that these tests are clinically or scientifically validated and provide a summary of the research to prove it.

I did have high hopes that I might see some evidence for scientific and clinical validation for allergy and intolerance testing when I read:
Imutest is a clinically proven IgE allergy test, just like those used in hospital laboratories. In a study of 200 patients referred to an NHS allergy clinic for allergy tests, Imutest correctly identified allergies present with an accuracy of 98% in comparison to the gold standard laboratory test method.
I tried to consult Imutest's website but it seems that they have recently gone into receivership. I searched Entrez PubMed and could not find a reference to Imutest. I contacted the journalist but it seems as if this claim was made in the material that was sent to her by Imutest and she no longer has the background research that she did for the piece. That's unfortunate: I don't have much disagreement with a well-conducted IgE test but I would have liked to have seen the reference. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I don't think that a test result is sufficient as a stand-alone diagnosis; a good diagnosis also depends upon a good clinical history that is interpreted by a clinician with relevant qualifications.

DIY Diagnosis refers to several YorkTest products: the YorkTest Food Intolerance Indicator, the YorkTest 42 Foodscan, the YorkTest 113 Foodscan and the Yorktest Multi-Allergy Screening Test. She writes the following about the reliability of the YorkTest tests:
All tests are highly accurate in diagnosis between 95 -97%. For the Foodscan range, 70% of those tested who followed the advice given reported an improvement in their symptoms.
I have looked high and low for an authoritative source for these claims about the YorkTest tests. I can't find them. I have seen these claims so often that I have to assume that there is reputable and substantial scientific literature to back them up but I have to declare that I have so far been completely unsuccessful in finding that research.

The journalist indicates that she discriminates between reliable, authenticated tests and those of a more dubious provenance. She mentions the BEST (Bio Energetic Stress Test) system and makes this comment about its reliability:
[c]urrently there is no clinical evidence to support this method of testing.
I would say that the current position of relevant professional bodies is that there is no clinical evidence to support the use of IgG testing in the diagnosis of food intolerance (more on the lack of support for IgG testing).

1. ARR!, 2. Yo ho ho, 3. Rogue Orange, 4. My New Pirate Hat

Created with fd's Flickr Toys.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Blogger super said...

With so many symptoms, it can get a bit tricky trying to diagonize and classify the allergy which affects a person.For food intolerance, it is good to note that the IgG blood test is a good enough indicator.


5:02 am  
Blogger Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

2:41 am  
Blogger Darren said...

Interesting post about More Allergy and Intolerance Testing Nonsense, in these days illness of any kind is very common and people have to try to be careful with their health, for example I unfortunately buy viagra only because I need it and well Im close to be a senior citizen.

6:01 pm  
Blogger hanly said...

Blu Ray Converter
Convert Blu Ray to AVI
Convert Blu Ray to MKV
Convert Blu Ray to MOV
Convert Blu Ray to MP4

2:50 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you are archers, this is an easy and good way for you to hunt and get some FFXIV GIL. There have huge cheap ffxiv gil in our stock. Make order when you need please. And always, always, ALWAYS! Pick up what the monsters drop; this gets you a nice sum of Buy FFXIV Gil to use on skills and potions and all other necessities needed. So it is very important for you to own much FFXIV Power leveling. Remember you can Final Fantasy XIV Gil in good price from our company.

4:00 am  
Blogger kimberly said...

I really love to go a spa, my body feel relax and comfortable with myself, i think everyone must to take a time to go a spa although be once per week, this practice is very healthy and it could help you even if you have sexual problems. Another alternative is to buy viagra. The spa is really good, i advice you.

9:19 pm  
Anonymous generic viagra said...

I used to have many allerges when I was younger, but my mom gave me some horrible natural mediactions, and since then I have not undergone allerges anymore

3:39 pm  
Anonymous buy viagra said...

I think that it is a big problem when we are young because It is so complicated to live, I think that this information can help to many people whit allerges.

9:28 pm  
Anonymous escort roma said...

Pretty worthwhile piece of writing, much thanks for the post.

10:31 pm  
Anonymous Buy Generic Viagra said...

cool,I would like to visit your town.
I feel so happy when I read more about it !

9:38 pm  
Anonymous sex shop said...

For my part one and all have to go through this.

12:26 pm  
Anonymous said...

This cannot have effect in actual fact, that's what I think.

6:53 am  
Anonymous said...

It won't work in actual fact, that is what I suppose.

7:23 pm  
Blogger runescape-powerlevel said...

Had repeatedly Rift Platinum said he is Mulan Runes of Magic Gold,if further annoy so me Dofus Kamas,Xuan Feng shock said: Having said Dragon Nest Gold,normally what a mighty.curled up body Dragon Nest Gold,Ye Gu Yun began to gradually R2 Gold transfer the original Swtor Credits feel only the breath of stagnant up Rift Gold,I feel very boring to turn on the general channel Guild Wars 2 Gold,the cold mountain breeze will rub the Troy Dra front said: He came here the 4Story Gold purpose is so Nostale Gold challenging to me,said Qi Hongguang's ancestors Troy Online Gold also had to foll ow the Japanese to attack the Great Grand Fantasia Gold Kublai Khan,surrounded by full of Maplestory Mesos hair flying
a green light Forsaken World Gold envel oped the Atlantica Gold entire cavalry corps headed by Zhao Bailong above Dragon Nest Gold.above a tree,but also War of Dragons Gold for their ruthlessness Cabal Alz,and instantly stop the oncoming force Flyff Penya.for him Atlantica Gold,and even Tin Fu Lu Wada clothes they Last Chaos Gold pull in behind the action did not hear him
rusty hearts gold
wow power leveling
Perfect World Gold

9:20 am  
Blogger moonlight said...

sex chatMelbourne SwingersI really love to go a spa, my body feel relax and comfortable with myself,

3:52 am  
Blogger kosovohp said...

I give good love
I’ll buy your clothes
I’ll cook your dinner too
Soon as I get home from work
I’ll pay your rent
Your faithful lover
Las Vegas Escortseffects of salvia

11:16 am  
Anonymous pharmacy reviews said...

I loved the picture! It looks like looks like you can create or simulate any person in "lego"

5:27 pm  
Blogger kosovohp said...

What kind of man
Would leave you standing in the cold
Must've been a silly one
To sacrifice a pot of gold
You're the kind of woman
That needs a man that's always there
strippers vegasEscort Milano

9:02 am  
Blogger kosovohp said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

3:31 pm  
Blogger kosovohp said...

socks5 | socks proxy | proxy free | proxy
socks proxy | socks5 | proxy | proxy free

8:24 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

free porn
free porn
free sex
escort bayan
free porn
film izle

11:16 pm  
Anonymous uggs boots said...

uggs boots Hongming still do, people are not finishing a heavy veteran tapped on the shoulder, MP02lq

uggs boots uk This time, other players have basically solved Xuelang outside the picket.

kids uggs boots bad: palace-like attire, with a kit under. Take the open look when there are small red

mens uggs boots People at the good news in the Yuan Shao, Yuan Shu at the reminder on to food.

5:25 am  
Anonymous price per head said...

Excellent blog! I truly love how it’s easy on my eyes as well as the info are well written. Great job!!

7:18 pm  
Blogger desea said...

sex video
asian sex tube
free teen
latin sex porn
secret porn
cute porn
sexy teen
cd porn
hot porn tube
sex video
fac sex
sex movies
xxx videos
teen sex
porn movies
porn videos
search porn tube
red tube
lesben porno

2:27 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

In this Cheap Diablo 3 Gold is among the problems regarding Necromancer: our own job auto mechanic will be unintuitive. Considering that it’ersus a brief express and some from the capabilities have throw periods GW2 Gems, we will need to experiment with this auto mechanic again and again right up until we a very good sense of this.

4:20 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Printing fully recognized matbaa profession in our country. A lot of people, or the history ucuz davetiye books as shown in the tape printing since Gutenberg nikah şekeri profession and an occupation which is carried out using Abraham Müteferrika'dan think that talking about the lead characters. bist canlı The development of technology has also affected the printing profession and became a computer-controlled machines used in production. Printing parts of the mostly male students prefer universities in the past years, while almost half of the canlı maç izle female students of classes today.

1:23 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

lig tv izle, Youtube, Facebook, Twitter ve daha birçok uygulamaya artık televizyonunuzdan ulaşabilirsiniz.IQ’dan izlediğiniz programları dilerseniz canlı maç izle facebook hesabınız ile sayfanızda paylaşabilir; You Tube üzerinden sınıflandırılmış video seçeneği ile fuar hostesleri veya arama seçeneği üzerinden videolara erişim twitter sağlayabilir.

1:34 pm  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home